• brambledog@lemmy.today
    cake
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Really?

    Please show me in which of Orwell’s writings he suggested that economies should be based off allowing financial criminals to commi their crimes against citizens, unimpeded.

    The thesis of 1984 is that when totalitarianism takes hold, we will turn on those we love to protect ourselves. Which specific portion of that novel do you believe told you that true freedom is getting your money stolen with no recourse?

    This is primarily the issue with libertarians. You guys are constantly applying a book you haven’t read to every situation you don’t like. It’s weird and I think people see through it.

    • zergtoshi@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      Please show me in which of Orwell’s writings he suggested that economies should be based off allowing financial criminals to commi their crimes against citizens, unimpeded.

      I don’t need to and I won’t, because I never said so.
      Please don’t put words in my mouth.

      The thesis of 1984 is that when totalitarianism takes hold, we will turn on those we love to protect ourselves.

      I was thinking of 1984, too; obviously.
      I see it in a more abstract way though.
      The consequences of mass surveillance, which are the basis of repressive regimentation of people are what makes lack of privacy dangerous and in my book not desirable - even if it has certain drawbacks, because abandoning privacy just has way more and more severe drawbacks.

      This is primarily the issue with libertarians. You guys are constantly applying a book you haven’t read to every situation you don’t like. It’s weird and I think people see through it.

      This is primarily the issue with people who think they know others because they’ve read one comment.
      It’s weird and I think people see through it.

      edit: typos