The problem in my opinion was the series originally launched exclusively on the ps and then set a $70 price tag which I remember being one of the first games to do so. Then in addition decided to split the story into three games to milk it further.
I can understand why it may not have been as well received, especially from those like myself who want a complete experience from the start.
Im with you on this one. Corporations are never your friend no matter how they try to frame it.