Tens of thousands of fraudsters splurged on Lamborghinis, vacation homes, private jet flights and Cartier jewelry by fleecing the PPP loan system in a $200 billion heist — and did it because the COVID loan scheme was so easy to milk.
Approximately $1.2 trillion was rushed through Congress in 2020 and 2021 in COVID bailout cash for businesses and spent on the Economic Injury Disaster Loan Program (EIDLP) and the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) schemes.
But a new report from the Small Business Administration’s Office of Inspector General reveals an astonishing 17% vanished to fraud — an estimated total of $200 billion.
And the SBA says it estimates there are more than 90,000 “actionable leads,” while it has already prosecuted dozens — including a former New York Jets wide receiver, Josh Bellamy.
Lamborghini Huracan Evo in blue. The Small Business Administration estimates 90,000 people made off with 17% of all COVID relief cash making it the biggest fraud in American history. This $318,000 Lamborghini Huracan Evo is just the tip of the $200 billion PPP fraud iceberg. US Postal Inspection Service David Hines behind the wheels of his Lamborghini. Miami-based David Hines spent thousands in COVID relief money at high-end shops, a Miami hotel and sent $30,000 in taxpayer cash to “Mom,” records show. US Postal Inspection Service The spending spree on taxpayer dollars includes Donald Finley, owner of the now-shuttered Manhattan theme restaurant Jekyll & Hyde, who purchased a Nantucket home across from Dionis Beach with waterfront views with millions of dollars from PPP and EIDLP.
Finley faces up to 30 years in prison, and paying more than $3.2 million in restitution, plus a $1.25 million fine.
And experts say crooks created fake businesses or lied about their numbers of employees to get access to more free cash — because it was so simple to fleece the taxpayer.
Donald Finley restaurant owner. Donald Finley used PPP and EIDLP loans to go on a spending spree. Marisol Diaz/Newsday via AP
“The fraud was so easy to commit. All of the information was self-reported and none of it was verified or checked,” Haywood Talcove of LexisNexis Risk Solutions told The Post.
“During the height of the pandemic, it was really hard to purchase [luxury] items like a Rolls-Royce, or a high-end Mercedes because you had people walking in with cash from the PPP program to purchase those items for whatever the dealer was asking,” Talcove said.
Justice might finally be catching up with some of the fraudsters: A total of 803 arrests have taken place as of May 2023 for pandemic fraud, the SBA said.
$30,000 for ‘Mom’ David Hines.
Details of PPP fraudster David Hines’ spending. This was how prosecutors detailed part of his spending spree as he blasted through $130,000 in just over a month, sending $30,000 to “Mom” alone. US Postal Inspection Service Florida-based David Hines, 29, from Miami, used $3.9 million in PPP money to buy himself a $318,000 Lamborghini Huracan Evo sports car.
The gased-up fraudster was caught when authorities seized the sports car and $3.4 million from bank accounts.
He pleaded guilty to one count of wire fraud. Records show he spent thousands at high-end shops and a Miami hotel, and sent $30,000 of taxpayer cash to “Mom.”
In Jacksonville, Fla., Kenneth Landers pleaded guilty to fraud in February after using PPP funds totaling $910,000 to pay off his mortgage at home and at his business property.
Vintage car, gold Rolex Kenneth Landers with his Rolex Kenneth Landers spent PPP loan money on this 18-carat gold Rolex watch and vintage Jaguar XK-E, among other personal expenses. An SK-E, or E-Type Jaguar Landers spent the cash on a vintage Jaguar XK-E, or E-Type, Roadster, and is facing 30 years behind bars. Barrett-Jackson via Getty Images But then he shelled out for an 18-carat gold Rolex watch and vintage Jaguar XK-E, or E-Type, Roadster.
He made a staggering $113,000 in cash withdrawals traced back to the PPP loans received.
Landers face a maximum penalty of 30 years in federal prison.
In similar expensive taste on taxpayer money, Georgia-based Darrell Thomas was sentenced to 15 years in prison for spending PPP funds on a Mercedes-Benz S-Class, a Land Rover, and an Acura NSX in addition to a gold Rolex.
Thomas pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit bank fraud and to money laundering for heading a scheme to obtain 14 fraudulent loans amassing $11.1 million from the PPP.
A Mercedes Benz S-Class Darrell Thomas picked up a Mercedes S-Class like this with his ill-gotten gains. A Honda NSX Thomas also bought himself an Acura NSX like this. But he cannot enjoy them anymore: He is spending 15 years in prison. Getty Images Restaurant scammer who also bars dogs In April, Manhattan restaurateur Besim Kukaj was revealed to have scammed $6.1 million in bogus loans to his restaurant group.
He owned Manhattan’s Intermezzo, Limon Jungle, and Cara Mia, which are all now closed.
But officials said he splurged on designer jewelry and clothing.
“He did this out of pure greed, sending some of this money to a Florida real estate developer and using it to buy luxury items from Cartier and Hugo Boss,” said Damian Williams, US attorney for the Southern District of New York.
Restaurateur Besim Kukaj with a glass of wine. Manhattan restaurateur Besim Kukaj refused to allow registered service dogs into his restaurants and failed to turn up at hearings for the violations in 2019. Intermezzo restaurant in Hell’s Kitchen Besim Kukaj used his restaurants, including Intermezzo in Hell’s Kitchen, Manhattan, as a front for a $6.1 million bogus loan scheme, then splurged on Cartier and Hugo Boss. Robert Miller “And he didn’t stop there. He directed his co-conspirator to physically threaten a victim to whom he owed money.”
The relentless fraudster pursued pandemic aid even after getting arrested and released on bail, the prosecutor said. Kukaj, whose restaurants previously barred diners with service dogs from entering, started a six-year, eight-month sentence at Fort Dix federal prison in New Jersey on Tuesday.
Plastic surgery and luxe travel In February, Leslie Bethea, of Surgoinsville, Tennessee, was sentenced to 78 months in prison for fraudulently obtaining a $20,805 loan in 2021.
She had claimed she was due the money because she had lost out on her 2019 income of more than $90,000 because of the pandemic.
But that was impossible because she was in prison in 2019 for fraud, prosecutors said.
Bethea used the scammed cash to fund a five-day trip at a resort in Sunny Isles Beach, Florida, according to court records.
Leslie Bethea mug shot. Leslie Bethea, of Surgoinsville, Tennessee, was sentenced to 78 months in prison for fraudulently obtaining a $20,805 loan in 2021. Hawkins County Sheriffâs Office Sunny Isles Beach, Florida Bethea headed for Sunny Isles, Florida, got cosmetic surgeries, and enjoyed five days away courtesy of a loan secured through lies. AFP via Getty Images She also used some of the dough for vanity — paying for plastic surgery during her trip. What she got done was not revealed by prosecutors.
And in April, Houston man Scott Jackson Davis was sent to prison and ordered to pay back $3.3 million after fraudulently receiving PPP loans for three fake businesses.
Instead of saving people’s jobs, he splurged on private jet travel, real estate, jewelry, guns, and a luxury vehicle, prosecutors said.
Ex-Jet received your cash Former NFL player Josh Bellamy obtained a $1.2 million loan for his company, Drip Entertainment LLC, in 2021 using falsified documents and false information.
Josh Bellamy. Former New York Jets wide receiver Josh Bellamy obtained a $1.2 million loan for his company, Drip Entertainment LLC, in 2021 using falsified documents and false information. AP Seminole Hard Rock Hotel and Casino in Hollywood, Fla. Bellamy did not spend the COVID bailout helping staff: Instead, he headed to the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel and Casino in Hollywood, Fla. AFP via Getty Images Bellamy — a Jets wide receiver from March 2019 until he was released because of injury in September 2020 — admitted to using the loan to fund a stay at the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel and Casino in Hollywood, Fla., and jewelry, admitting to investigators he shelled out more than $311,000 to a reported co-conspirator.
He was released from federal prison in June after serving most of his 37-month sentence.
I don’t understand- I had a business that was devastated by Covid. When applying for aid so I didn’t have to fire my employees because we were closed, I was put through the ringers and only awarded 50% of what I needed. It took weeks of paperwork and I’ve since been paying it back. How did these guys get so much free money? Any bank or agency I talked to required pay roll deposit proof for the 18 prior months, all employees info, taxes for the prior 3 years, operating expenses and so on.
They lied - they lied on staff numbers, they lied on operating expenses, they lied on wages, they lied and lied and lied
I couldn’t lie, I had to provide bank records, tax info, pay roll receipts- everything. Did they find a willing bank somewhere that didn’t ask for proof?
If you were creative and unscrupulous, you probably could have come up with something. Forged documents or the like.
But then there’s that.
I guess so, jerkface.
I’ve read from other business owners that it was all about having connections at the bank. A lot of small business owners never saw a dime of PPP money because by the time they were even let in the door, all the big businesses and connected people that didn’t need it had soaked up all the loans.